Key takeaways from Canada leaders' election debate

15 days ago
Posted by news
298 views
Key takeaways from Canada leaders' election debate


Media playback is unsupported on your device
Media caption'You are a phony, you are a fraud': Leaders spar in Canadian election debate

For the first time in this campaign, all Canada's main party leaders were on stage together in what is likely to have been the most watched TV debate in this federal election campaign.

So the stakes were high.

It was a crowded stage - the most leaders at one debate in Canadian political history: Liberal leader Justin Trudeau, Conservative leader Andrew Scheer, NDP leader Jagmeet Singh, Green Party leader Elizabeth May, and People's Party of Canada leader Maxime Bernier.

Did any of them standout from the crowd? Were there any performances sharp enough to finally shift opinion polls that have barely budged since the election was called mid-September? What topics sparked fireworks?

Here are some key takeaways.

Justin Trudeau v Andrew Scheer

The Conservatives and the Liberals have been locked in a dead heat for the entire campaign, so this was a chance to get some momentum before Canadians head to the polls on 21 October.

Both need to break that deadlock - and the two frontrunners frequently went head-to-head, occasionally talking over each other to the point of incoherence.

Image copyright Pool via Reuters
Image caption Conservative leader Andrew Scheer clashes with Liberal PM Justin Trudeau

Andrew Scheer attacked Mr Trudeau straight out of the gate - slamming him as "a phony" and "a fraud" who doesn't deserve to be re-elected, and continued to go after him repeatedly on two issues that have been his Achilles heel with voters: the SNC-Lavalin affair and the blackface scandal.

With SNC-Lavalin, a federal ethics commissioner found the prime minister improperly tried to influence his former minister to prevent the construction company being prosecuted for corruption - a political crisis that saw Mr Trudeau slump in the polls earlier this year.

But the Liberal leader's electoral fortunes seem to have recovered despite old images of him in blackface surfacing in September.

And pivoting on Mr Trudeau's frequent attempts to link the federal Conservative leader with Ontario Premier Doug Ford, who has made unpopular budget cuts in the vote-rich province, Mr Scheer snapped: "You seem to be oddly obsessed with provincial politics".

Mr Trudeau proved willing to fight back and make his Conservative political rival his rhetorical punching bag, forcing him to defend his stance on social issues such as abortion rights.

Mr Scheer is "personally pro-life" but has repeatedly said that if elected, his party would not put forward or support legislation that would regulate abortion.

The Liberal leader also defended his record in government, including a strong economy, less poverty and low unemployment.

The fight for the progressive vote

Canada's progressive voters have a wealth of choices in this election campaign: Mr Trudeau's Liberals, Mr Singh's NDP, Ms May's Greens, and, in Quebec, Mr Blanchet's Bloc.

Image copyright Reuters
Image caption NDP leader Jagmeet Singh

Mr Trudeau is hoping for a repeat of the 2015 federal election, when those progressive voters coalesced around his Liberals, sweeping them to victory.

Jagmeet Singh worked hard to position himself as a reasonable third option between Mr Trudeau and Mr Scheer.

He was frequently able to break into the discussion and get his pitch across to voters: that his party is "in it for people, we're not in it for the rich", and to land some of the more memorable zingers of the night.

After a heated debate between Mr Trudeau and Mr Scheer over their climate plans, he jumped in with the line: "You do not need to choose between Mr Delay and Mr Deny".

Elizabeth May reserved her sharpest attacks for climate issues, repeatedly calling Mr Trudeau's climate targets "a commitment to failure".

She also made a direct appeal to voters to cast their ballots for the Greens so they might hold power in a minority situation.

The stakes for the Bloc's Mr Blanchet were relatively low on Monday night.

Few English-speaking voters in Quebec would be considering casting a ballot for his sovereignist party, which only runs candidates in that province.

The Bloc leader mostly focused on issues central to Quebecers, like Bill 21, the controversial provincial secularism law that bars civil servants deemed to be in positions of authority from wearing religious symbols at work.

He will have another chance to make an appeal to voters in a second French-language leaders' debate on Thursday.

Trudeau defends his climate record

Climate change has emerged as a major issue in this federal election and Mr Trudeau clashed with other leaders over how his government has handled the issue over the past four years in power.

Image copyright Reuters
Image caption Party faithful and protesters await the party leaders outside the debate venue

The Liberal leader repeatedly called his climate change plan "reasonable and doable" - a dig at other federal parties like the Greens, which have more ambitious climate targets than the Liberals' current commitments.

Since he was first elected in 2015, Mr Trudeau has always pitched the possibility of finding a balance between the economy and the environment - and he has to convince voters again that a Liberal government is best placed to do just that.

But he has come under pressure for buying a crude oil pipeline for C$4.5bn ($3.4bn; £2.6bn) last year to help ensure a controversial project to triple its capacity would move forward.

"You bought a pipeline - you can't be a climate leader," Ms May told Mr Trudeau on Monday night.

"I have accepted the fact that I'll be attacked for not building pipelines from some, and for building pipelines from others," he replied.

Wildcard Bernier

People's Party of Canada leader Maxime Bernier was a late addition to the debate lineup. Polling nationally in the low single digits, he was originally excluded before the national debate commission reversed its decision.

He made the most of his time on the stage, frequently interrupting the other leaders.

Mr Bernier has courted controversy as a political leader, including with Twitter rants against the "cult of diversity" and young climate activist Greta Thunberg.

He is also seeking to limit the number of immigrants to Canada - for which he was attacked from all sides on the debate stage.

The leader of the newly formed right-wing federal party also argued for balancing Canada's budget.

His inclusion in the debate was criticised by Mr Singh, who told him that he did not "deserve a platform".

"It's not because I have a different point of view that I'm not supposed to be there," Mr Bernier later told journalists.

With files from the Canadian Press

Source :
www.bbc.co.uk